On Account of Sex
"The fight must not cease; you must see that it does not stop."
-- Susan B. Anthony
copyright Landau Entertainment, Inc.
All Rights Reserved
On Account of Sex
is the story of a conflict between two giants of American history --
one famous, the other forgotten. His name is Woodrow Wilson. Her name
is Alice Paul.
Their conflict created a revolution in American
life that began with women demanding the right to vote and still
resounds, unresolved, in the battle for equal rights around the world.
In 1913, having taken Susan B. Anthony’s words to heart, Alice
Paul is in Washington, D.C., on a mission to win a solitary thing: the
vote for all American women through an amendment to the United States
Constitution.
Woodrow
Wilson is about to become a controversial President. Publicly, he is
stern, impassive and absolutely tyrannical in his use of executive
power. Privately, he is warm and funny, and utterly dependent upon his
wife and three daughters. Wilson, though proud to be called a Champion
of Democracy, can’t figure out why women would even want to vote. The
whole notion is antithetical to his worldview.
From Alice Paul’s
point of view, to be disenfranchised in a Democracy is the consummate
Injustice. Molded by the Quaker faith as she was, Righteousness and
Injustice are as real to her as Jesus and the Devil. Alice Paul can no
more give in to Injustice than she could give in to the Devil.
This
delicate and dark-eyed 27-year old galvanizes an army of gentle ladies,
turning them from housewives into soldiers. Armed with faith,
determination, and the knowledge that they have right on their side,
these amazing women, young and old, pursue Justice with all their
might. The result: they are systematically brutalized and tormented,
imprisoned and force-fed.
Why did they endure such punishment?
For something we take for granted today, "The right of citizens of the
United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United
States or any other State on account of sex."
PROLOGUE
Our
story begins in a retirement community, in the late 1970’s. An 80-year
old resident, Doris Stevens, sits on the porch basking in the morning
sun. Her eyes are closed and she listens to her granddaughter, Jess,
read The New York Times. When young Jess reaches the obits, she wiggles
her nose in mock disgust, but reads on, A to Z. When she gets to the
"P’s" and names Alice Paul of Pennsylvania, Doris bolts up and
dissolves into emotion. Jess, alarmed, wants to know what is wrong.
Doris pulls herself together and begins to explain.
"Oh, Jess,
you wouldn’t have liked her -- not in the beginning, anyway. I didn’t
like Alice Paul one bit the first time I met her. She scared me to
death. She looked meek, but it was a disguise. She was the most
powerful person, man or woman, I ever met. She was a force of nature
who always got what she wanted out of people, including me."
THE CHALLENGE
Doris
takes us back. "I remember that first day in Washington, DC, as if it
were yesterday. We’d had a long train ride from Nebraska. I’d come with
some girls from my college. We were tired and ecstatic all at the same
time. Miss Paul and her Congressional Union group set up an office on F
Street and we were there early. Oh, you couldn’t miss it. Even at eight
o’clock in the morning there was a riot of color outside and a beehive
of activity inside.
"The very first time I saw Miss Paul, she
was in a state. It was only hours before the president-elect’s arrival
and preparations for his reception did not appear to be going very well.
"Then
suddenly, in what seemed like a perfectly random act, Alice Paul points
to me, of all the people in that room, and says, ‘She’ll attend to it.
What’s your name?’ Before I could answer, she orders me to have new
trappings made for the horses, as theirs had just been ruined, and make
sure they are beautiful and here by two o’clock.’
"Well, I had
absolutely no idea what she was talking about. I told her I knew
nothing about horses or sewing. But she wouldn’t take "no" for an
answer. She just turned her back and walked away saying something about
Woodrow Wilson speeding toward Washington. She just assumed I’d leap
into action, which, of course, I did. Did I mention there were
sixty-four horses to dress? Oh my, I was terrified. I didn’t know what
to do, but I certainly didn’t want to be the one to spoil it the
President-elect’s reception."
Our story continues with parallel
scenes between a heartwarming farewell for an exuberant President-elect
Woodrow Wilson, leaving Princeton and whistle-stopping to Washington
DC, and the hectic, last minute preparations Alice Paul and her gleeful
army of volunteers are making for his reception.
Spirits soar
aboard Wilson’s coach. A butler pours brandy for the men. A faithful
and admiring group surrounds the President-elect. His wife Ellen, his
three daughters, Margaret, Nellie and Jessie (all in their twenties),
his favorite cousin, Helen Bones, his loyal advisor, Colonel House, and
his flamboyant Irish Secretary, Joseph Tumulty.
Wilson’s trusted
friend, Dudley Field Malone calls for a toast, "Tomorrow Woodrow, we
will all have the pleasure of addressing you as Mr. President. May I
have the distinction of being the first?" He raises his glass. "Mr.
President." Everyone, "Mr. President."
Ellen takes Dudley’s arm
and tells him that they wouldn’t be standing on the threshold of this
great new era if it hadn’t been for his support. "This is your victory,
too, Dudley; and, if I know Woodrow, he has something very special
planned for you."
" What would you say to Collector of the Port
of New York?" Woodrow asks his good friend "You’ll have to give up that
thriving practice of yours, Counselor." Dudley is overwhelmed.
At
Headquarters, Alice is lovely in lavender and white. She orchestrates
events from the back room, perched atop a desk. Behind her, a beautiful
painting of Susan B. Anthony hangs on the wall.
Lucy Burns, a
flaming redhead and Vassar graduate, is second-in-command. "You’ve been
working for hours, Alice, and you still haven’t taken off your hat. You
can’t be that busy."
Alice ignores her and continues to delegate
tasks to volunteers, one of whom we follow out the door into the coming
and goings that is the Women’s Congressional Union Headquarters.
We
see a wide variety of women from all over the country and all walks of
life, working together in a sea of lavender, white and gold.
Along
President-elect Wilson’s train route, smiling faces and out-stretched
hands greet him and confirm his belief the country wants and needs him.
Someone in the group pipes up: "Look at all these people. Isn’t it
exciting? I can’t wait to get to the Capitol."
Margaret,
Wilson’s eldest, suggests to her father that since the people are so
behind him now, he can do something for suffrage. But Wilson has his
own ideas and chides his daughter, "Women should be worshipped and
adored, my dear little girl. Their place is on a pedestal, not in
politics." Nellie, the youngest, agrees with her father: "Women in
politics are offensive, don’t you think so, Mother? Why would you want
to vote?"
Ellen, the perfectly gracious Southern wife, supports her husband.
"Five minutes to Union Station."
The
energy is as palpable at Headquarters as it is on the train. Back and
forth, we intercut between Alice and the President-elect until his
train comes to a hard stop in Pennsylvania Station.
When the President and his entourage disembark, the station is surprisingly empty and quiet.
The silence is broken when small brass military band strikes up a welcome.
Wilson
is baffled. "It’s so quiet. Where the devil is everybody? An
embarrassed official tells him, "Down on Pennsylvania Avenue, Sir,
watching the parade."
Pennsylvania Avenue is ablaze with banners
and bands. The procession is a thing of beauty parading down the Avenue
to the White House.
Ten thousand people march. Some carry
banners. Some wave flags. The largest banner’s message is written in
gold letters: We demand an amendment to the constitution of the United
States enfranchising women of the country.
The crowd is huge.
500,000 people line the avenue watching, cheering. Many of the
spectators are out-of-towners in the Capitol for inauguration
festivities. That is why the crowd is so big. Alice Paul couldn’t have
planned it better.
Horse-drawn carriages carry the President-elect and his entourage to their new home, The White House.
Pennsylvania
Avenue is so crowded now that the marchers have to slow down. A
bystander takes exception to a banner’s message. The situation turns
ugly fast. One man, disgusted and disgusting, stubs his cigar out on
the banner-carrier’s arm. Another fellow trips a marcher: then another,
and another. One man spits on an elegantly dressed older woman. This
incites a spectator to fisticuffs. Before you know it, it is a
free-for-all.
The crowd pushes through the barriers, forming a
sold mass. People are being hurt right and left. Someone in the crowd
yells, "Go back to the kitchen where you belong."
"Tramps, the lot of ya."
"Leave ‘em alone. They got their rights."
Police,
mounted and on foot, do nothing to stop the carnage. The marchers are
incensed. They show a proper parade permit issued by Congressional
Resolution.
Lucy Burns seeks out the police command post and
brandishes their permit. It states that Pennsylvania Avenue must be
kept clear for them.
The authorities are indifferent. This is odd since these are the very same men who issued the parade permit in the first place.
En
route, Wilson’s two carriages can’t avoid the action. The President
eyes Alice. She eyes him back. Wilson’s women are aghast at what they
see happening on the Avenue. "Who is that woman?" The President asks.
"I believe that’s the leader, sir," the official answers.
A cavalry officer gallops hard to redirect the President’s carriages before they get to close to the mayhem.
At the same time, troops arrive from Fort Meyer to restore order to Pennsylvania Avenue.
Pandemonium
reigns at Headquarters. The battered and bruised share war stories.
Husbands search frantically for their wives." One berates his injured
wife: "You got what you deserved. I told you not to walk with them
radicals."
In midst of the hubbub, a nurse cleans a scraped
elbow and bleeding knee, a doctor consoles a sobbing old woman even as
he puts salve on a nasty burn on her arm, and a loud, disgruntled
husband pulls his wounded wife out the door, yelling, "I’m still your
husband and you’ll do as I say!"
Alice Paul steps up to a
makeshift podium. Newspapermen hurl questions at her. "Don’t you think
it was bad form to organize that kind of a parade today?
Alice
answers politely. "Absolutely not. It was Mr. Wilson himself who
provided us with the impetus. He said that the machinery of political
power must be put into the hands of the people. We agree. Millions of
women and men will no longer tolerate a government which denies women
the right to vote!"
The reporters scribble as Alice continues,
"The President has it in his power to bring full Democracy to America.
We have only one aim: The immediate passage of a Federal Amendment
enfranchising women. What we do in the future depends entirely on what
the President does now."
Back in the present, Doris opines
dreamily, "I’ve often thought Miss Paul didn’t get her full measure of
respect as a mover and a shaker. Hindsight being 20-20, it seems so
clear to me now: That day she gave birth to the press conference.
She
notices Jess is skeptical. "You don’t believe me? I can see it in your
eyes. But it’s true. Alice Paul, long ago, figured out how to shape
public opinion by using the press. That day was just the start.
"Later
that night, I remember, when things had calmed down, I knocked on her
door. When she invited me in, I told her I had come to say goodbye. She
was surprised. I explained I had to go home to help my family in
Nebraska. She said ‘No.’ Just like that. Well, I was so flustered I
didn’t know what to do. I heard she was rude, but this was shocking.
"‘Nothing,’
she told me, ‘is more important than securing the vote for American
women, not even your family. You are able, Miss Stevens. We need you
here to handle publicity.’ I told her I didn’t know anything about
publicity."
"‘Well, find out then,’ she said. I stayed. It was
just impossible to say no to that woman. And believe me, I wasn’t the
only one who couldn’t say no."
At the White House, Wilson is
mesmerized by Lincoln’s bedroom. His first childhood memory is
Lincoln’s assassination. Ellen walks in and interrupts his reverie to
tell him their guests have arrived.
In the Salon the Wilson girls gather around the piano with a few of Washington’s most eligible bachelors.
Margaret
asks, "Did you hear what they did to those suffragettes? Some of them
are in the hospital. They were attacked by hooligans."
"Not now, Margaret" Ellen admonishes her daughter.
A young reporter, David Lawrence, approaches the President, "Glad you could join us, Lawrence."
Lawrence remarks that the American people wish him well in spite of the incident on Pennsylvania Avenue.
"Oh
it does me good to have my thunder stolen once in a while. But enough
of this female carrying on. Tell me about the Austrian Ambassador who’s
coming to breakfast tomorrow. Is he Bismarck’s man?"
"Right down to the dueling scar, sir." Lawrence replies.
On
March 17th, Alice Paul leads a delegation to the White House and asks
the President to include suffrage in his message to Congress. She tells
him it is the most important issue before the country.
The
President can hardly hide his amusement. "I’ve never given suffrage any
thought at all, he tells her. "It is my job to see that Congress
concentrates on currency and tariff reform."
"But Mr.
President," Alice replies, "Do you not understand the Administration
has no right to legislate for currency or tariff or any other reforms
without getting the consent of women?"
"I assure you ladies I will give the subject careful attention."
Doris
tells Jess, "About that time we published the first edition of the
Suffragist, thanks to the generosity of Mrs. Vanderbilt. It was an
entertaining weekly, with a big circulation. It was filled with
editorials, reports, sketches, verse, and cartoons. You name it.
"Alice Paul also established a Press Department. My job was to keep the action of the party always in the public eye."
About
a year after his election, at dinner one night at the White House, the
conversation turns to suffrage. Much to Wilson’s chagrin, all three of
his girls have chosen careers. Margaret works hard to be a concert
singer. Jessie, dreamer of the family and Phi Beta Kappa, works in a
Philadelphia settlement house. Nellie, Wilson’s youngest, is married to
Wilson’s much older Secretary of the Treasury and, like her mother, is
an artist studying commercial illustration at Philadelphia’s Academy of
Fine Arts.
Nellie is a suffrage convert. She has come to see a
certain injustice in her own family. Her dear mother plays a
significant role in her father’s success but she never gets any credit
for it. It doesn’t seem fair to Nell, though she doesn’t know quite how
to go up against her father.
The discussion at first is lively
and loving, but when things get hot, Wilson short-circuits the debate,
performs his nonsense verse and soon has everyone is stitches.
FORMING A WOMAN’S PARTY
Spring,
1914. Alice Paul’s group renames itself, The National Women’s Party.
They choose this name after rejecting the strategy, or lack thereof, of
the more mainstream women’s suffrage group. Having broken away, they
are bona fide radicals and decide to increase pressure on the President
by bombarding him with delegations.
Doris tells Jess what
happened: "When we were shown into the office we found four chairs
lined up, one placed in front, facing the other four. Just like a class
with the president as master."
"At the President’s side, I saw
your grandfather for the first time. He just listens to Alice lobby the
President to support a federal amendment enfranchising American women."
Exasperated,
President tells Alice, "I am merely the spokesman of my party, I am not
at liberty to urge on them, or Congress, matters of policy.
"But Mr. President," Alice says, "If you cannot speak for us and your party will not, pray who is there to speak for us?"
"You seem well able to speak for yourself, madam."
"I
mean, Mr. President, who will speak for us with authority — since you
continue to deny us the authority to speak for ourselves?" Abruptly,
the President signals an end to the meeting and ushers the delegation
out of the door.
Later at dinner, the President comments to
Dudley that it had been a splendid day with the exception of that
dreadful meeting with those suffrage women. His daughters’ ears perk up.
Wilson
goes on, "My principal objection to giving women the ballot is that
they are too logical. A woman’s mind leaps instantly from cause to
effect without any consideration whatever for what lies between. She
thinks too directly to be enfranchised en bloc."
No one knows
what to say. After an awkward silence, Wilson in his inimitable way,
acts the clown, recites some odd verse and changes the subject.
Ellen,
tired and wan, asks everyone’s forgiveness and excuses herself from the
table apologizing that she must rise early to tour the slums and
inspect housing.
When she leaves the room, everyone worries she’s sacrificing her own health on behalf of the city’s poor.
Meantime,
Alice Paul turns Headquarters into a center of political action and,
occasionally, gossip. Volunteers are stuffing envelopes while Mabel
Vernon reads a magazine aloud. Several stories feature the Wilson
girls. A Congressman’s wife complains she’s sick of reading about them.
"They are more before the public than any other White House family I
have known."
Then Mabel says, "Listen to this, Mrs. Ellen Wilson
bought seven new gowns ranging in cost from $200 to $300 each. Can you
imagine?"
One lady defends the First Lady. "She’s an artist. She
earns her own money selling paintings. Why shouldn’t she buy what she
wants?"
Another adds, "Personally, I don’t think she gets the credit she deserves. You know she gives her money to charity."
In
the back room at Headquarters, Alice plots strategy with Lucy, Doris
and Mrs. O. H. P. Belmont. Lucy says the President’s a hypocrite.
"Everybody knows his party does exactly what he tells them to do."
"What
matters," Alice answers, "is that he is President of the United States
of America and the leader of his party. Only he can change the status
quo. I have the utmost respect for the President’s idealism. That’s
reason enough to hold him personally responsible for securing the vote
for women. We must work harder, that’s all."
The girls in unison, "Harder? That’s not possible!"
"Yes it is." Alice says, "I’m going to give up all personal pleasures until the amendment passes both Houses."
"Ridiculous!" Doris exclaims, "What could you possibly give up?"
"Detective stories. From now on, I’ll read only politics and law until we’ve won. And we will win."
Doris
brings us back to the late 1970’s. "I thought it impossible for her to
work harder, but she did. She worked day and night. She solicited and
contributions poured in. She recruited and volunteers flocked to
Headquarters. Alice Paul believed enthusiasm beat experience every time
and so she chose young, fresh, inspired and inspiring spirits. She
instilled in them, and me, confidence and the feeling that in spite of
obstacles, we could conquer the world.
"The problem was she
worked so hard, she became frail and ill. We worried about her, but she
brushed us off and kept right on working.
"She wouldn’t let
anything stand in her way, not even the President. The next time she
called on him, she gave him a copy of his own book, The New Freedom,
and told him by substituting the word ‘woman’ for the word ‘men’ it
would make the best argument for suffrage ever written. She was
brilliant when it came to using the President’s words against him."
Then,
two tragedies shatter Wilson’s world. Ellen, his beloved wife,
exhausted by working for Washington’s poor black slum dwellers, dies.
At her funeral, Congressional Representatives vow to pass the slum housing legislation she worked so hard to implement.
Almost simultaneously, Germany declares war on Russia.
The President is distraught. He spends a lot of time in Ellen’s attic studio looking at paintings.
Dr.
Grayson comes in to check his pulse and vitals. He puts his stethoscope
to his ears and listens. "Sir, we all share your grief. There are some
hard years ahead. You owe it to yourself and the American people to
move forward with your great programs."
But Wilson is paralyzed
by grief. The nation clamors for war. Dissension tears his Cabinet
apart. Migraines become a daily torture.
Wilson has never been
able to withstand criticism. Without Ellen, his confidence
disintegrates. No one can console him, not even his daughters. Finally,
his cousin, Helen Bones (who had served as Ellen Wilson’s social
secretary) moves in to help her cousin Woodrow run the White House.
By
February of 1915, news of the President’s inactivity fuels the rumor
mill. Dr. Grayson conspires with Helen Bones. They must do something to
improve the President’s state.
"I believe only a woman can pull
him out of his misery." Grayson tells Helen. This gives Helen an idea.
"I know the perfect person."
March 1915. Alice leads a
delegation to the White House where they find the flag at half-mast.
While waiting to see await the President, the ladies speculate the
First Lady’s death was the result of tuberculosis she contracted while
working the city’s slums.
Lucy points to the irony: The
President has just introduced segregation into government lunch rooms
and offices where it had never been before while his wife gave her
lifeblood to improve the lot of these very same people.
A
presidential aide escorts the delegation in to the President’s office.
Dudley and Dr. Grayson are there, as is his faithful secretary, Joseph
Tumulty.
Alice finds a heartsick and desolate President. Though
sympathetic, she won’t be put off. Doris and Dudley exchange looks
again while the President insists he can’t urge policy on his party.
"The world is on the brink of war," he admonishes, "I am much too busy
trying to keep the peace to think about suffrage for women."
"But,"
Alice says, "there is no matter more important than justice for women."
Abruptly, the President ends the meeting, ushering the women out. On
her way out the door, Alice tells the President if he doesn’t urge
immediate passage of a federal amendment enfranchising women, she will
campaign against his reelection.
When the women are out of
earshot, Wilson explodes. "Oh! That damnable woman! Won’t she ever give
up?" But a smile wipes away the anger when he spots Nellie, Helen and a
very attractive woman waiting in the wings.
By their
expressions, it is clear they witnessed the exchange. Helen changes the
mood with her greeting and introduces him to her good friend, Edith
Bolling Galt. "Mrs. Galt can trace her ancestors back nine generation
to Pocahontas and John Rolfe, isn’t that fascinating?"
The
attraction is immediate. After months of gloom, the President is
laughing. Mission accomplished. The White House comes alive again.
Forty-three-year-old
Edith Bolling Galt is a strong-willed Southern widow. Five feet nine
and fashionably dressed, she radiates confidence. Her exuberant
independence is tempered with just the right amount of subservience
that Wilson finds essential in women.
This glamorous and
exciting woman lifts the President out of his depression into the
elation of a great romance. They have two basic things in common: a
reverence for their fathers, and for the South.
As Europe
plummets into war, Edith becomes Wilson’s obsession. Before long, he
consults her on matters of policy. He secretly installs a phone line in
her house connecting her to him directly.
In June of 1915 the President vacations in New Hampshire. Edith is there ostensibly as Helen Bones’ guest.
Though
Wilson’s daughters are elated over their father’s romance, they worry
about the rumors that are spreading. A nation still grieving for the
First Lady is shocked and outraged by the President’s behavior.
Wilson’s
cabinet speculates on how on the romance will affect the President’s
political fortunes. Cabinet members fear Edith’s power should she
become First Lady. Only Colonel House, Wilson’s most trusted advisor,
and Joseph Tumulty, his secretary, are bold enough to speak the truth.
For both, it proves a fatal career mistake.
It strikes those at
National Woman’s Party Headquarters that it’s unseemly for someone
whose wife is dead only six months to be romancing another woman. Alice
tells them, "The President’s personal life is none of our business.
It’s his public life with which we must be concerned. We must do
something splendid to remind him that nothing is more important than
enfranchising half of all Americans. I have an idea…"
Some weeks
later on a golf course, a Secret Service Agent stands a discreet
distance from the President, who hits a fair drive from the tee. Edith
nods approvingly and steps up to the tee. She sends the ball sailing to
the green. Wilson whistles in admiration and they set off across the
links.
The President complains that Alice Paul and her noisy
friends had the nerve to deliver a petition today, a hundred feet long
and filled with signatures. "That woman had the unmitigated gall to
invite newspaper people to what she billed as my acceptance speech."
"What a nerve!" Edith exclaims. "She is a rude young woman. A pity too. She’d be quite attractive if she wasn’t so impertinent!"
"I’d
call her down-right devious," Woodrow goes on, "I’m to speak at the
Belasco next week, part of a panel on the subject of Democracy and war.
Somehow, that dreadful woman has managed to insinuate herself on the
list of speakers."
"Shameless. Perhaps you should send Dudley, on your behalf, to debate the clever Miss Paul."
Amused, Wilson responds, "Capital idea, my dear little girl. Why didn’t I think of that?"
The
Belasco Theater. A large crowd is assembled for the debate. Edith and
Helen are seated in the audience. Edith is disconcerted when she sees
Doris on the dais instead of Alice. When Dudley takes his place and
sees Doris, he’s momentarily unnerved.
But ever urbane, Dudley
Field Malone argues eloquently for the President’s interpretation of
Democracy as it relates to the war in Europe. A question rises about
suffrage and democracy. Dudley promises the audience the President will
urge Congress to consider suffrage after he is reelected. "The
President has assured me that he will do so."
Edith whispers to Helen, "That doesn’t sound like your cousin to me."
When
it is Doris’ turn, she urges the audience to vote for Hughes because he
favors suffrage now. A stranger in the audience stands up and shouts,
"That’s right! The President has eyes for only one women while he
ignores the rights of all women." There is a collective gasp. Edith
fans herself.
By March 1915, Alice has a new plan of action. She
lays it out at an advisory council meeting in New York City. "We need
to organize in every State of the Union. We cannot allow the people of
the United States to forget the Suffrage fight. Therefore, we are going
to form a nation-wide organization that will focus on Congress. Here’s
how."
"First, we will hold a convention in each and every State
and explain our purpose, our plans, and our ideals. Then, each State
convention will choose a representative to send to a culminating
convention of women voters in San Francisco. This convention, to be
timed to coincide with the Panama-Pacific Exhibition, is in September.
"At
that convention we will choose representatives to take a petition to
Congress and the President demanding that women be enfranchised.
"We
want to make women’s suffrage the dominant political issue from the
moment Congress reconvenes. We want Congress to open in the midst of a
virtual suffrage cyclone."
On May Day, on behalf of the National
Women’s Party, Alice Paul sends a May Day basket to the President. It
is brimming with purple, white and gold flowers. Concealed in their
midst is a message: May the coming year bring you joy and the Susan B.
Anthony Amendment.
That night, there’s a party aboard the
presidential yacht Mayflower. It is a lovely, star-filled night.
Romance is in the air. A band plays "Moonlight Bay."
The
President draws Edith away from the other guests. The two of them lean
against the railing. He appreciates the flower pinned to her dress.
"You are the only woman I know who can wear orchids. Usually, the
orchid wears the woman."
Edith takes his hand. It would be a
magical moment, except Edith senses the President’s uneasiness and asks
what’s troubling him. He confesses he can’t seem to keep the affairs of
state in their 9 to 5 niche. Those damnable suffragists are driving him
to distraction with their ill-advised, theatrical tactics. Dissension
rages in the Cabinet over war: should we or shouldn’t we? It is enough
to give him a permanent migraine.
Edith asks about the Cabinet.
He explains. "The majority threatens to resign if I warn the Germans,
as I plan to do, that we are going to take up arms against them."
"My
advice to you, dear, is take them up on their suggestion and thank God
for the chance. Then you can replace them with people who are loyal and
who will respect you and the office."
Wilson laughs. "You’re not only beautiful, my dear, but astute. How did I get so fortunate?"
The
magic moment triggers the President to propose. Edith is shocked,
mortified. "Oh, dear me, Woodrow it is too early to speak of such
things. We mustn’t." Wilson begs her to reconsider.
Colonel
House and Dudley overhear this part of the conversation and are
shocked. They support Edith. "A quick marriage will only hurt your
chances for reelection next year, Mr. President."
"Nonsense," the President counters.
The
President asks Edith repeatedly to reconsider. She explains she’s lived
in the capital too long to have missed the public’s fascination with
whoever happens to occupy the White House. "Tourists hound the
president’s family. And I hate snoops and they are a part of Washington
life. But most important, we must allow an appropriate interval to
elapse."
On August 29 and 30 the very generous Mrs. O. H. P.
Belmont opens her palatial home in Newport to the National Women’s
Party and select members of the press.
The house is magnificent. Decorated in the colors of suffrage. The mansion is flooded in a golden light.
Political
leaders, trade-unionists, women of wealth and position, women active in
the communities, professional women of every sort, artists and artisans
are all gathered here to hatch a plan to hold.
Alice Paul asks
the press to withdraw and outlines a national election strategy. "The
Democrats have been in control of all branches of government and they
are therefore responsible for the non-passage of our measure.
"The
point is: Who is our enemy and how shall that enemy be attacked? We now
lay before you a plan. We propose going to the nine Suffrage States and
appealing to the women to use their votes to secure the franchise for
the rest of the country. Now the time has come to go into national
politics and use four million votes to get the vote for the rest of us.
The stage this time is the entire United States of America."
By the middle of September they are all at the Panama-Pacific Exhibition in San Francisco, at a Convention of women voters.
Mrs.
Belmont opens the Convention, "We women of the North, of the South and
of the East, branded on account of sex, disenfranchised as criminals
and imbeciles, come to the glorious West, where the broad vision of its
men has seen justice."
Mrs. Fremont Older, the novelist, is
next. "I thought Women Suffrage was like Utopia. When women were good
enough to vote, the men would give it to them. But I have learned that
Utopias are not given away; they must be fought for."
Dr. Yami
Kin, the first woman physician in addresses the gathering. "All
countries look to North and West for inspiration and help in their
march toward freedom."
Mme. Maria Montessori, the famous Italian
physician and educator, makes a point. "We have watched individual
States in your country give justice to women, one by one. Now we’re
waiting for the United States to declare its women free."
Doris
points out President’s inconsistency. In Philadelphia, the President
welcomes a great army of naturalized immigrants, but denies a hearing
to American women.
In the exhibition hall, the national Woman Party’s booth, displays the Record of the Sixty-third Congress.
All
visitors are asked to look up the record of their Congressman to
discover how he voted on the Suffrage Amendment. Then they are asked to
sign a monster petition.
Sara Bard Field describes it for the
Suffragist. "The world passes by and looks reverently up at the sweet
face of Susan B. Anthony whose portrait hangs upon the wall."
The
convention passes a resolution calling on the Sixty-fourth Congress to
vote for the Susan B. Anthony Amendment. Several young women, including
Doris, are chosen as envoys to carry the Resolution across the country
to its destination.
The final ceremony of the convention takes
place in the Court of Abundance. A thousand orange lanterns sway in the
breeze. A band plays.
Mrs. Belmont accepts a bronze medal in
recognition of the work done by the Congressional Union, on behalf of
the National Woman’s Party.
Ten thousand people witness her
acceptance. The large crowd comes from many countries and many are in
native costume. Members of the Congressional Union wear surplices of
the organizations colors.
Framing the stage is a great curtained
arch that flutters in red, white and blue. Hanging with the Stars and
Stripes is the great suffrage banner: WE DEMAND an amendment to the
constitution of the United States Enfranchising women.
Everyone
sings the Song of Free Women (sung to the Marseillaise), and escorts
the envoys, who carry the lighted torch of liberty, to a big overland
touring car bedecked in the color of suffrage.
As they drive away, cheers burst forth from the well-wishers and the crusaders are off and on their way across country.
The
car travels every type of terrain and stops in towns and farms all
along the way. In Reno, Salt Lake City, Colorado Springs, Kansas they
enlighten and amuse.
At every stop a bigwig, Mayor or a
Governor, welcomes the envoys. As their petition grows, Doris keeps
track of events in her Suffragist articles.
Chicago. Indianapolis. Detroit. Albany. The crowds grow larger.
In national newspapers, the story of their journey pushes European war news off the front page.
Meantime,
the President and Edith compose their wedding announcement. Afterward,
the President types out a press release announcing he will vote for
suffrage in his home state of New Jersey where it is on the state
ballot.
Edith doesn’t understand. To her, suffrage is a threat to the future of the family, to the country.
Wilson
reassures her, "I believe it is the right thing to do at this time, my
dear little girl. And beside, If I support the women’s cause now, it
will force the gossip mongers to talk about something other than the
circumstances of the president’s remarriage and whether or not he now
sleeps in a double bed.
The pilgrimage from San Francisco logs
five thousand miles as the car drives into Boston. A huge reception
welcomes them. The demand banner still flies from the car, though it
has seen better days. A hundred cars, all beautifully decorated with
balloons and purple ribbons, gold and white chrysanthemums follow the
weather-beaten touring car to the pier where it is put on a boat to New
York City.
From New York, the car is on to Washington where it
is met by a group of women on horseback, representing all the States in
the Union.
They carry a replica of the Liberty Bell, and bear a
petition with five hundred thousand signatures. The petition is so
long, it requires 20 people to carry it.
The motorcade’s first stop is Congress. They climb the Capitol steps to the music of the Marseillaise.
A
reception committee, composed of senators and representatives, meet the
women at the top of the Capitol steps. Speeches are made. Then, it’s on
to the White House.
Edith insists the President refuse to see
women. The President cannot. Alice Paul has invited the press, whom he
accuses "of favoring the interesting over the important."
The
President receives the envoy in the East Room where Mrs. Joliffe asks.
"Help us, Mr. President, to a new freedom and a larger liberty. You
have said it was a matter for the States to decide. But we have watched
you change and develop your mind on preparedness, and we honestly
believe that circumstances may change your mind in this regard."
Mrs.
Field asks the President to look at the petition. He unrolls a portion
of it and says, "I did not come here anticipating the necessity of
making an address of any kind."
Doris glows,
remembering the moment. "About then, Jess, something heavenly happened.
Mrs. Belmont, bless her soul, bought us Cameron House, a beautiful and
well-appointed mansion, and we were finally able to move out of that
dark, smelly basement on F. Street.
"Cameron House was terribly
famous, you know. It had been occupied by Senators and Vice Presidents
before us. It was perfectly situated for our purpose -- 21 Madison
Place -- just across from the White House.
"Everyone called it
‘The Little White House’ because from the windows of the big White
House, you could see our great banners and colorful flags. This
infuriated the new First Lady, which hadn’t been our intention, of
course, but caused no end of amusement."
December 18, 1915. Surrounded by family and friends, Edith Bolling Galt and the President exchange vows in Edith’s posh home.
Wilson’s daughters are joyous, though Margaret jokes to Dudley, "This union will set suffrage back a million years."
"Not true." Dudley replies a bit indignantly. "Your father will declare for national suffrage. He told me so himself."
After
the wedding reception, the Presidential limousine carries an elated
Edith, her maid and her many trunks to her new home and life as First
Lady. When Edith sees her new neighbors’ welcome, a brightly colored
banner proclaiming, "The Little White House" Headquarters of the
National Women’s Party. Votes for Women, a cloud crosses her face.
"We’ll see about that!" She mutters.
Late that night, a light
still burns in a second floor window. Inside, President Wilson teaches
Edith the secret code he uses to communicate with his European
emissary, Colonel House. From now on, Edith encodes and decodes every
message. Beside the President, and much to the chagrin of Wilson’s
cabinet, she is the only one who knows the whole foreign policy picture.
The
White House comes alive under Edith’s direction. She entertains often
and sits devotedly by the President’s side. She constantly instructs
Elizabeth Jaffray, head housekeeper for 14 years, on how she wants
things run at the White House.
Valentine’s Day, 1916, Cameron
House is again ablaze with banners. This time the colors are red and
white. Inside a thousand valentines are being inscribed so they can be
dispatched to each and every Senator and Representative in Congress, as
well as to the President and Vice President. The words may vary for
each Valentine, but the message is fundamentally the same.
Representative Pou’s Valentine, for example, shows an exquisitely
ruffled little maiden curtsying to a gentleman who is presenting her
with a bouquet. Underneath it reads:
The rose is red
The violet’s blue,
But VOTES are better
Mr. Pou
Cameron
House proves a splendid Headquarters. It is an exciting place - the
kind of place lots of gay and interesting people drop into easily.
Organizers,
the young women Alice dispatches to distant parts, return here with
news and new ideas. The Press Department works hard to keep their work
in the public eye.
At this point, the President and First Lady
cannot come or go without confronting Alice’s troops. Everything Alice
does irritates the First Lady. The pageantry. The stunting. Everything.
There is no surcease.
One thing that makes Alice Paul a great
general is her sense of timing - as soon as she exhausts one tactic,
she enthusiastically attacks another. At an executive meeting at
Headquarters, Alice outlines a new action.
"Our plan is this: to
send at least two women to each of the nine States in which women can
vote. We put one woman at the center that attends to the organizing,
publicity and distribution of literature. The other visits all the
large towns of the State and speaks at every opportunity. First,
however, we must raise seven thousand dollars to underwrite the
mission."
There is a farewell garden party for the organizers.
Teams are dispatched to the nine enfranchised states. Lucy Burns and
Rose Winslow leave to open a San Francisco headquarters.
Doris Stevens and Mrs. Belmont are off to Colorado.
Doris’
articles for The Suffragist, tell the story. "In Denver the Senator’s
daughter gave us a drawing room, in her beautiful home in which to have
our meeting. She invited representatives, women and men from all
Parties, to come and hear of our work. One hundred women showed up. The
meeting was a splendid success judging from the large number who joined
the Union and gave generously."
In another article, she writes,
"At town meetings I find the women very open to reason. The one thing I
had not expected was to find how chivalrous all the men are. I have
never been so overwhelmed with courtesy and chivalry as I am out West."
At
a church picnic, Doris rallies women to vote against the President as
he has done nothing to secure justice for a full half of all Americans,
and is surprised to find herself face-to-face with Dudley Field Malone,
the President’s emissary to Western women.
"Like Thomas
Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln before him, Woodrow Wilson is a man of
high ideals and great vision." Dudley says in his speech. "I assure you
President Wilson has taken the suffrage question to heart. He has
promised that in his next address to Congress he will urge them to
introduce a federal amendment enfranchising all American women."
After the speeches, Dudley approaches Doris. "You are a passionate speaker, Miss Stevens.
"And
you, Mr. Malone, are a persuasive apologist for the same old party
line." Dudley retorts, "Shall I take that as a complement?"
It
is an electric encounter for these two soldiers who serve different
masters. It is clear their mutual fascination will not end here.
Back
in Washington, Dudley courts Doris. He’s put off by Alice’s tactics and
militant philosophy and says so. Doris tells Dudley, "Alice Paul is a
woman who walks apart. She does what she does for Justice. Faith is her
guide she knows she has right is on her side. The President has said it
himself, ‘It is the right of those who submit to authority to have a
voice in their own government.’"
"Touché, Miss Stevens."
Doris
and Dudley are occasional guests at the White House. At dinner one
night, much to Dudley’s chagrin, Doris discusses justice for women.
Edith tells her home and family are the true goals of a well-adjusted
women. Doris is about to disagree when Dudley kicks her under the
table. Her "ouch" stops the conversation and the President takes over
telling one of his silly nonsense stories. Soon, everyone except Doris
is laughing.
By the time the 1916 election, voters are worried
about the war in Europe. Many believe it will involve us and, if it
does, the Republican candidate Charles Evans Hughes would be a better
commander in chief. The Congressional Union and National Women’s Party
support him. The election is up for grabs.
Election night, 1916.
At Headquarters they are waiting for the results from the voting booths
out West. Doris is confident that Colorado’s women will defeat the
President. Mrs. Helena Hill Weed is certain that no Democrat will come
to Congress from Wyoming or from the West. Lucy and Rose are pretty
sure that California will go to Hughes. Alice is not so sure.
"Regardless, we will have made our point simply by reducing the
President’s majority. He dare not ignore us now."
Wilson’s
family and friends are gathered at the White House waiting for the
news. The men play pool. The women chat nervously. The election returns
are disappointing. Edith declares the American people haven’t shown her
husband the appreciation he deserves.
When the President
realizes he’s won California by only 4000 votes, he is miffed. "It is
that damned Miss Paul’s doing. Why can’t she behave like an normal
woman?"
The President knows now that a suffrage amendment will
pass, but he has just been re-elected and can take his time doing
anything about it.
Knowing that the President is safe for four
years, Alice realizes she must devise another method to keep suffrage
front and center in his mind. They must find a way to make him
personally want the immediate enactment of the amendment. That is the
key.
By this time, Alice Paul has a nationwide organization in
place - 50,000 women. 5,000 of whom are in Washington at her beck and
call. These women are organized into squadrons, each with clearly
delineated responsibilities.
When Inauguration Day dawns cold,
wet and windy, Alice summons a raincoat company to Headquarters and
issues a thousand sets of tarpaulin hats, coats and rubbers.
The
same morning, for the first time in history, a woman, Edith Bolling
Galt Wilson, rides in the presidential carriage to the Capitol. She is
the only woman present at the swearing-in ceremony. But her day of
glory is spoiled when she returns to the White House and finds several
bands and a shocking sight -- a thousand rain-drenched women circling
her home with placards asking: Mr. President, How Long Must Women Wait
for Liberty? Edith fumes.
Later that night, when the President
and First Lady are alone, Edith tells her husband, "You must do
something about these detestable suffragettes. They are tarnishing your
reputation. They ought to be punished."
Through a White House
insider, Alice discovers President Wilson is not going to mention
suffrage in his Congressional address though he had promised to do so.
She retreats to her office to consider her response. It is important to
make the public aware of the President’s hypocrisy.
On the day
of the President’s address to Congress, Alice leads five ladies to the
Capitol with a plan to inject the message they now know the President
will leave out.
These soldiers for justice take front row
gallery seats. At a pre-arranged moment in the President’s address,
Alice unpins a banner hidden under her skirt and drops it over the
balcony. It snaps smartly asking: Mr. President, What will you do for
Women’s Suffrage?
Spectators gasp. The President falters. The
First Lady is beside herself. Giggles come from the gallery. Guards
force their way through the crowd, but Alice and her troops have
planned for this. They are strategically placed to slow down the
advancing guards. A comical scene unfolds as guards try to move around
these demure roadblocks.
Finally, a Page jumps up and yanks the banner down.
Later
that evening, Democratic Party heavyweight, J.A. Hopkins and his lovely
wife Alison, host a dinner party. Alice and Alison are friends from
Swarthmore. Alison has arranged to bring Alice and the President
face-to-face in this informal setting in the hopes it will help the
cause. Her husband is opposed. He does not trust Alice, but Alison
assures him he has nothing to worry about,
Just as the President
and First Lady arrive, Alison whispers to Alice, "You get more with
honey than with vinegar, Alice. Be friendly. This is a dinner party. I
promised A. J. you’d behave. Please, Alice."
Alice struggles
with small talk. The conversation turns to war. The President says it
grows increasingly difficult to remain neutral. Somebody speculates
we’ll join the war soon. Alice says if America goes to war, it will be
the lifeblood of women that is sacrificed. Allison throws her a look.
A.J. is annoyed. Alice continues, "You can’t ask American women to give
you their sons, Mr. President, if you will not give them the vote."
You
can hear a pin drop. Alison is mortified. A.J. throws her an "I told
you so." Edith bristles. Someone breaks the tension and changes the
subject, but Alice won’t be put off and proclaims the fight for
political freedom for women will not be put aside because of the war.
On
her way out, Alice whispers to Allison, "It will take more than honey
or vinegar to change his mind." Allison ignores the comment and blasts,
"How could you!"
Alice responds, "How couldn’t I?"
At an Executive Meeting in Cameron House, Alice and her lieutenants discuss a new strategy they call "The Perpetual Delegation."
Alice
lays it out this way: "If a creditor stands before a man’s house all
day long, demanding payment of his bill, the man must either move the
creditor or pay the bill."
THE PERPETUAL DELEGATION
January
10, 1917, twelve women walk out of Cameron House, march across
Lafayette Square to the White House. Four carry a lettered banner and
eight carry purple, white and gold banners of the Women’s Party.
Six
women take up a position at the East Gate, six at the West gate. There
are two banners at each gate. One reads: MR. President what will you do
for Woman Suffrage? The other says: How long must women wait for
liberty? From now on the pickets are on duty at the gates 24 hours a
day.
The president, raised to believe that chivalry always wins,
sends his secretary, Tumulty, to invite the picketers in for tea. He is
upset when they refuse.
Now each afternoon when The President
and First Lady drive through the big iron gates on their way to play
golf, they cannot escape The National Women’s Party’s messages. The
placards now carry the President’s own words: Resistance to tyranny is
obedience to God. Governments DERIVE THEIR just power from the consent
of the governed. This is too much for Edith.
She suggests to her
husband, picketing should be against the law. He tells her the right to
picket is guaranteed by the Clayton Act. She says, "Well, it shouldn’t
be." He says, "Don’t worry. These silly women will tire of it soon. It
is getting cold."
But he is wrong. The picket line, dubbed
"Silent Sentinels" by the press, is tireless and become a cause
celebre. They picket every day of the week except Sundays. They picket
in rain, sleet, hail, and snow. All kinds of people picket, all races,
all classes, all professions and all parties. The spectators are
friendly and curious. Children stop to spell out the inscriptions.
On
freezing days, Sherman, the janitor, trundles over from Headquarters
with a wheelbarrow piled high with hot bricks. The pickets stand on
them to keep warm. A newspaper describes it this way. "At the end of
the day, when the pickets step down, it is like a line of statues,
stepping off their pedestals.
Meanwhile the German campaign of
sea terror keeps more and more ships at home. Goods pile up on wharves
and in warehouses. More and more, Americans demand their government
protect sea-going commerce.
The subject is debated in a Cabinet
Meeting. Wilson reproaches the "champions of belligerency," and tells
them he will not risk war by arming American ships, no matter how
blatant and hostile the German government acts.
Then Wilson
receives an intercepted message from the German Foreign Secretary
Zimmermann to Germany’s minister in Mexico City, proposing an alliance
with the Mexico whereby they would join with Germany in a war on the
United States. In return, Mexico would receive in return the "lost
territories in Texas, New Mexico and Arizona."
All sides bombard
the President with advice. He goes into seclusion, from March 12 to the
20th. Edith reports the President is in spiritual agony contemplating
his choices. Then, the Germans deport thousands of Belgians as forced
labor for the Reich. This is the last straw.
WAR
Wilson
sits down at his battered typewriter and pecks out his war message. He
is suffering another migraine. Edith brings him milk and grahams to
calm his nerves. She rubs his neck trying to relieve his tension.
On
the night of April 2nd, the silent sentinels take their places at the
Capitol steps. The Capitol grounds are overrun with pacifists. Cavalry
troops stand by. At 8:30 in evening the President addresses a joint
session of Congress:
"We shall fight for the things which we
have always held nearest our hearts - for democracy, for the right of
those who submit to authority to have a voice in their own government."
From the halls of Congress comes a deafening thunder of applause.
At
Headquarters, someone asks about the impact of the war on their plans.
"War or no war, we will be at the White House gates," says Alice.
Everyone knows this will be unpopular. "Political power for women
serves the highest interest of this country." Alice reminds them. "What
is the point of fighting for freedom abroad when we don’t enjoy it at
home?"
A new sign goes up at the White House: An autocrat at home is a poor champion of liberty abroad.
Some
Party members quit on the spot. But new members join up all the time.
After war is declared, unexpectedly, money pours into headquarters
doubling receipts providing Alice with the means to keep things
interesting.
Throughout the spring the pickets stand at the
White House Gates. Alice breaks up the monotony by staging special
events. This triggers a storm of criticism and hostility.
Alice
Paul is steadfast. She reminds everyone that when the Civil War broke
out, suffragists of the day were begged to give up their fight and work
for the war effort. They were told then that they’d be enfranchised
after the war. With great reluctance, Susan B. Anthony complied. The
result? At the end of that war, the black man was enfranchised, but
women were still asking to vote. "We are not going to make the same
mistake."
The eyes of the world are on the White House.
Distinguished men and foreign missions come one after another to visit
the President.
When Balfour, the leader the British Mission,
calls, he is confronted with 40 pickets carrying banners featuring the
words the President spoke before the joint session of Congress: "We
shall fight for the things which we have always held nearest our hearts
- or democracy, for the right of those who submit to authority to have
a voice in their own government."
The day the English, French
and Russian missions arrive to meet with the President, the banner
addresses the President as "Kaiser". This incenses a young man in
uniform and he pulls the banner down, stomping on it.
A brave
soul in the crowd yells out, "Leave ‘em alone. They got their rights."
Another shouts, "This is a free country, isn’t it?" A skirmish breaks
out.
Edith witnesses the action from her second floor window and
gives her husband a blow-by-blow of the scene at the gates. Wilson,
suffering from another migraine, reclines on a chaise.
Mortified,
Edith tells her husband the Russian Ambassador is actually waving his
approval. "Damned embarrassing." the President mutters. Edith can
hardly contain her fury, "Miss Paul is not only insulting, she is
dangerous. You must do something, Woodrow."
Across the way, Alice watches from her window.
The
next day, a prominent newspaperman shows up at Headquarters and tells
Alice he fears the President might be assassinated by someone in the
crowd attracted to the pickets.
"Is the Administration willing to have us make this public?" Alice asks.
"Oh, no. Certainly not," the newsman stammers.
"The picketing will go on as usual, then." Alice informs him.
By
summer, a wave of patriotism engulfs the nation. Washington’s streets
are filled with the colors of khaki and navy and the sound of boots. At
the picket line, the placards seem suddenly provocative, although they
only carry the President’s words.
An outraged soldier dashes out
of the crowd and drags Alice Paul across the muddy street, tearing her
dress. A sailor comes to her rescue, and he is attacked.
The
skirmish turns into a riot. The angry crowd presses toward
headquarters. The crowd throws eggs and epithets. Two soldiers throw a
ladder up against the building. Young men crawl up and tear down the
American flag and the tri-colored flags hanging off the balcony.
Shots
ring out. Bullets crash through the windows. Through it all, Doris and
Lucy stand on the balcony with flags fluttering until, a soldier pulls
Doris from behind back and rips at her clothes, cursing. At this
moment, with much fanfare, the police arrive and restore order.
An
angry Police Chief, Major Pullman, calls on Alice and warns her, "If
you picket again, we will arrest you." Alice says, "Our lawyers assure
us picketing is perfectly legal. Certainly it is as legal in June as it
was in January, and March, and April and May." "I warn you," the Chief
bellows, "if you picket again, you will be arrested. I’ve got my
orders."
The next day, rows of policemen surround Cameron House.
As a diversionary tactic, Alice sends scores of women in and out of the
mansion. The cops don’t notice Lucy and Doris leaving Headquarters with
a box. The two cross Lafayette Park and meet up with several others
women. Together they unfurl a banner which says: Mr. President, You
SAY, "Liberty is a fundamental demand of the human spirit."
They
are momentarily unobserved. Then a policeman spots them, "You little
devils." Another cries, "Arrest ‘em!" Another intervenes, "My God, man
you can’t arrest ‘em for that. Those are the President’s own words."
After
a few comical moments of indecision, the police do arrest Lucy, Doris
and twelve others. They are pushed into a Black Maria and driven to the
police station.
Both Alice and Edith watch the action from their respective windows.
The
next day the pickets are on trial in the court of the District of
Columbia. They refuse counsel. Lucy leads the defense and demands their
banners be admitted as evidence.
When the banner is unfurled in
the courtroom, everybody bursts into laughter. No one can quite believe
they’ve been arrested for carrying these words: Mr. President, you say
"Liberty is a fundamental desire of the human spirit."
The judge
is not amused. He accuses the pickets of treasonable behavior and
sentences them to 60 days in the workhouse for "obstructing traffic."
THE WORKHOUSE
At
the Occuquan workhouse, these genteel ladies are humiliated and treated
like common criminals. Issued numbers, they are stripped of their
possessions including their money and jewelry.
Mrs. Belmont
hands over her very expensive diamond and pearl necklace to the warden,
admonishing him to put it in a safe place. The warden is flustered.
The
prisoners are herded into a dormitory. A matron orders them to strip.
Then she orders sixteen regular prisoners, mostly poor black women, to
take off their vermin-infested rags and give them to the pickets.
Everyone
is in shock. Lucy is defiant. Two guards grab her, viciously dragging
her out of the room by her hair. Old Mrs. Nolan, 75 and lame, tries to
help Lucy.
She is manhandled, dragged out of the room, across a
courtyard, down a dark corridor and thrown her into a cell where she
hits her head on an iron bedstead.
Not a single picket escapes injury that night.
Meantime,
the picketing continues. One day, six women appear at the White House
gates. They are immediately arrested. They refuse to pay a fine. The
Magistrate sentences them to 30 days in the government workhouse
A few days later, four more are arrested and given the same sentence. This goes on day in and day out.
At
the workhouse, the ladies soon discover their cellmates are rats and
tuberculars. The women are forced to use the same piece of soap and
share the same drinking cup with the "regulars." They are forced to
scrub toilets barehanded.
They are denied counsel and held incommunicado.
Mealtime
is a special torture. There are worms in everything set before them.
The ladies make sport of collecting the worms that float in their soup.
Each table counts up its score of weevils and worms. Lucy collects them
and presents them to the warden. He retaliates. Manacling her ankles
and wrists, he throws her into solitary.
Meantime, old Mrs.
Nolan is on death’s door. When the workhouse authorities realize she
might die in their care, they quickly release her. She carries word of
the horrors back to Headquarters.
Alice calls a press conference
and recounts in vivid detail what happened the night the ladies were
put in jail. She calls it the "Night of Terror" and the story makes
headline news across the country.
Doris writes in the
Suffragist. "No woman there will ever forget the shock and the hot
resentment when we were told to undress before the entire company,
including two negress attendants and a harsh-voiced Matron, who kept
telling us it was after hours and, they ‘had worked too long already
today,’ as if it were our fault that we were there. We silenced our
impulse to resist this indignity, which grew more poignant as each
woman nakedly walked across the great vacant space to the door less
shower."
What the President hadn’t realized when he authorized
the arrests, was two wives of his associates were imprisoned. Both men,
Hopkins, and Gardner (a well-known newspaper man), call on the
President separately, to protest the treatment their wives are
receiving at the hands of the workhouse authorities. The President
tells each he is shocked and disavows any knowledge of what is going on
at Occuquan.
Dudley also calls on the President. He vigorously
protests the circumstances of the picket’s imprisonment. Again, Wilson
claims he has no knowledge of the situation. Dudley tells him he knows
now.
When Dudley leaves, Edith explodes, "Dudley is impertinent. It is obvious his loyalties lie elsewhere!"
The
next day the President pardons the prisoners. Within hours Alison
Hopkins is at the White House gates with a banner: We ask not pardon
for ourselves but justice for all American women. While she stands
there, the President passes through the gates and salutes.
The picketing continues, attracting tourists in sightseeing busses and women in motorcars.
Crowds
streaming home in the afternoon from offices often comment when banners
strike a chord: I have no son to give my country to fight for democracy
abroad so I send my daughter to Washington to fight for democracy at
home.
Ex-Senator Henry W. Blair, white-haired and ninety, visits
the soldiers at the gates. He tells them he was a friend of Susan B
Anthony’s and made the first speech ever in the Senate in favor of
suffrage. They are pleased to meet him and he shakes and kisses each
picket’s hand.
The ladies’ intention is to keep complete silence, but the throngs passing by have questions that need answering.
"Why
are you doing this?" Someone asks. The answer is always the same: "The
President asked us to concert public opinion before we could expect
anything of him. We are concerting upon him."
Another question. "Why don’t you go to Congress?"
"We have, again and again. Congress tells us if the President wants it, it will go through."
Laborers
digging trenches in the street nearby show the picket’s their support
by making wooden supports for their banners. They offer benches, too,
but the ladies refuse. "Sentinels," they say, "stand at their posts."
A
stranger comes up and addresses the silent sentinels that flank the
gates "I wonder if you realize what a medieval spectacle you young
women present? You’ve made me realize you are on a crusade."
Though
the President does his best each afternoon to ignore the action as he
passes through the gates, it annoys Edith. She refers to the silent
sentinels as "those devils".
In an effort to get the President
to take action, Alice ups the ante and sends Elizabeth Stuyvesant to
the picket line with a new banner: Kaiser Wilson, have you forgotten
your sympathy with the poor Germans because they were not
self-governing? Twenty million American women are not self-GOVERNING;
take the beam out of your own eye.
Kaiser! That is the last straw. Edith snaps. She begs her husband to do something about those detestable suffragettes.
On
September 13th, six pickets leave Headquarters at half past four in the
afternoon. Two young women carry a lettered banner: How long must women
wait for liberty Mr. President, What will you do for suffrage?
In
the dying light of the afternoon, it is an ethereal sight. Dressed in
lavender, holding the great golden banner and their tri-colors high,
the Silent Sentinels seem to sail to the White House gates.
Several policemen and a crowd are gathered there. The spectators make way for the pickets. No one knows quite what to expect.
Moving picture men record the event until the police confiscate their cameras; destroy one of them in the process.
Gladys
Greiner snaps pictures of the crowd. She levels her Kodak at a police
captain. He kicks her. She continues taking pictures. Her pictures will
later accompany Doris’ articles.
A policeman orders a sailor and a marine to move away from the pickets. Instead, they push closer.
Suddenly
the sailor snatches the banner and tears it apart passing the scraps of
to friends. The police don’t interfere. Then, they arrest the women.
The
pickets appear in District Court before Judge Mullowny. He rules all
evidence, except that given by the policeman, inadmissible.
As
to the police captain who kicked Mrs. Greiner, the Judge says, "I have
nothing to do with those things; they have nothing to do with the case."
Then he asks, "Would you ladies pay the fine instead of going to prison if I made the fine fifty cents?"
"Not if you make it five cents." Mrs. Kendall tells him
The Judge bangs his gavel and sentences them to 30 days.
On
September 22nd, twelve women, standing a few feet apart, flank the
White House gates like living statues. Their banner quotes the
President.
A policeman calls the banner " seditious." Another
shouts orders. More blue coats come and elbow their way through the
crowd. A patrol car clangs in the distance and the pickets are no
longer flanking the gates
In court, the women tell the judge
they are not citizens, as they are not represented. "We were silently
and peacefully attempting to gain the freedom of twenty million women
in the United States of America. We have broken no law. We are guilty
of no crimes." They are sentenced to thirty days for "obstructing
traffic".
The next four pickets who leave Headquarters are
stopped at the curb by a patrol car. The policeman tells them to move
on, and then promptly arrests them.
In court the choice is pay a
25-dollar fine or spend six months in the district workhouse. More and
more women go to the workhouse.
October 20th is a blustery day
at the White House Gates. Bundled up, the pickets stand on hot bricks.
Government clerks going to and from work pause to read the banners.
Alice
watches from her window as Doris reads a message smuggled out of prison
where 46 women are now incarcerated for "obstructing traffic." Alice
sees the patrol wagon coming in the distance. She grabs her coat, hat
and turns back for a book, which she tucks in her drawers. Doris pleads
with her not to go.
Alice exits her office and takes the stairs,
all the time dictating the things that need to be done in her absence.
Doris begs her not to do this.
"Your job is to carry on," Alice
tells her while she chooses a gold-lettered banner with the slogan: the
time has come to conquer or Submit. For us there can be but one choice,
WE have made it." These are the very words Wilson has had stamped into
every Liberty Bond Loan of 1917.
At both the East and West
Gates, the pickets are being arrested and herded into waiting patrol
cars. There’s a large crowd today. Many applaud the women.
When
Alice reaches the picket line, she, too, is dragged to a patrol wagon.
On the way, she tells a reporter, "I am being imprisoned not because I
obstructed traffic, but because I pointed out to the President that he
is obstructing the progress of Democracy and justice at home while
Americans are dying for it abroad."
From her vantage point,
Edith is triumphant. At last the leader is behind bars. Now those
detestable suffragettes will stop harassing her poor, beleaguered
husband.
Eleven women including Alice Paul are on trial. The
arresting officer testifies: "I made my way through the crowd that was
surrounding them, and told the ladies they were violating the law by
standing at the gates, and would not they please move on."
Assistant
District Attorney Hart asks the officer if they moved on and the
officer replies, "They did not. They didn’t answer neither so I put
them under arrest. Those were my orders."
When it’s the picket’s
turn to address the Court, they refuse. They won’t be sworn. They won’t
question witnesses. Instead, Alice Paul speaks for the record:
"We
do not wish to make any plea before this Court since, as an
unenfranchised class, we have nothing to do with the making of the laws
which have put us in this position."
Judge Mullowny is annoyed
and gives them a choice between a twenty-five dollar fine and six
months in the district workhouse. The pickets refuse to pay. He
sentences Alice Paul and the other banner carrier, Caroline Spencer, to
seven months in jail. The rest he sends to the workhouse for six months.
JAILED FOR FREEDOM
Alice
is taken to District Jail the same day. There she finds ten other
confined earlier. They are miserable and complain that no fresh air is
allowed in the cellblock. Alice reaches into her under drawers and
pulls out her cherished copy of Browning. After the briefest
hesitation, she sends it crashing through a window. A gush of air
rushes in and a round of applause echoes through the cellblock.
Called a troublemaker, Alice is thrown into a "punishment cell." From here, she organizes a hunger strike.
From
solitary Alice rallies her troops. A charwoman carries messages to
Doris instructing her to keep the pressure on. She tells Doris to send
a message to the President demanding that all pickets be treated as
political prisoners.
On Monday the District of Columbia Commissioner Gardner makes a statement saying such demands will never be met.
When
news gets out that Alice Paul is in jail, held incommunicado, women
come from all over the states to join the picket line. Every day there
are more and more pickets. And every day there are more and more
arrests.
With Alice and Lucy in prison, Doris is in charge.
She’s upset because she cannot find out where the prisoners are being
kept. Though sentenced to the District Jail, they are not being held
there. Dorris gets an idea.
She meets the morning train — the
one that usually carries released prisoners from Occoquan and gets
lucky finding a released prisoner who updates her on the situation:
Sixteen women join Miss Paul on the hunger-strike including Mrs.
Lawrence Lewis and Lucy Burns. None has eaten for more than a week.
Worried,
Superintendent Whittaker tries to get the women to sign a paper saying
they themselves were responsible for any injury upon their health. The
women refuse. The Superintendent yells, "All right, you can starve!"
On
Sunday night, nine days into the hunger strike, the Superintendent
loses resolve and approaches Mrs. Lewis to ask what can be done.
Mrs.
Lewis tells Whittaker the pickets want to be treated as political
prisoners. They should be free to exercise, to receive mail, visitors
and reading material.
Whittaker barks at he to write all their
demands down. He takes her statement to the Commissioners the District
of Columbia. Commissioner Gardner makes a statement that such demands
will never be recognized.
Matthew O’Brien, the women’s lawyer gets an order from the Court to admit him to Occoquan. Whittaker refuses him entry.
Meantime,
inside, authorities suspect Lucy is somehow facilitating communication
between all those locked up. To lower her morale they take her clothes
away.
When O’Brien does finally get to see her, he finds her wrapped in blankets in a dark cell looking poorly.
Those
on the hunger strike both at Washington Prison and Occoquan grow frail
and sickly. Many share quarters with tubercular and syphilitic
prisoners.
Superintendent Whittaker worries that Mrs. Lawrence
Lewis and Lucy Burns will die. Unbeknownst to the other prisoners, he
takes them to the hospital and force-feeds them.
Lucy smuggles a
note to Headquarters: "Yesterday at about four o’clock Mrs. Lewis and I
were taken to the operating room. Dr. Gannon said he wished to examine
us. We refused. We asked for a woman physician.
"We were dragged
around. Our clothes were removed and we were examined against our will.
We do not make it easy. It takes Dr. Gannon, two other doctors, a
matron, and four colored prisoners to hold us down.
"I refused
to open my mouth so Gannon pushed a tube up my left nostril. When the
tube came out it was covered with blood. It made me very, very sick.
Food dumped directly into the stomach feels like a ball of lead."
In
court we find out the real reason the two women were removed to the
hospital. They had a court date. To prevent their appearance in court,
Whittaker tells the Judge Miss Burns and Mrs. Lewis are too ill to
appear.
Dudley Field Malone, representing the women, tries to
show the court that Superintendent Whittaker removed Lucy Burns and
Mrs. Lawrence after having received the writ of habeas corpus.
Dudley interrogates Whittaker and asks if the women are being force-fed. The warden replies, "They are not."
Then Dudley asks, "How many men does it take to hold Miss Burns while she is being force fed. Whittaker answers, "Four."
Dudley
turns to the Judge, "Then, your Honor, don’t you think that if it takes
four men to hold Miss Burns down to force feed her, she is strong
enough to appear in Court?"
The next day, both Mrs. Lewis and Lucy Burns are before the judge. He finds their detention illegal and frees them on parole.
Mrs. Lewis and Lucy refuse parole for they committed no crime. Back to prison they go.
The
next note smuggled out comes from Washington Jail where Alice and
several others are confined. The note is from Rose Winslow.
"Miss Paul and I have been in solitary for five weeks.
"Yesterday
was a bad day for me in feeding. I was vomiting continually during the
process. I fainted again last night. The same doctor feeds us both.
"Don’t
let them tell you we take it well. Miss Paul vomits constantly. The
feeding gives us severe headaches. I cry and sob to my great disgust.
It is quite against my will. I’ll try to be less feeble-minded. Miss
Paul is such an inspiration."
November 9th, forty-one women go
down to Washington Jail where Alice and others are held. Warden Zinkman
is in charge here. His house is close to the wing in which Alice is
imprisoned.
Three women ring the warden’s doorbell. When the
door opens they ask to see the warden. They are told the warden is too
ill to see them.
The three give a prearranged signal to a silent
crowd behind them. With one accord the group crosses the grounds and
cluster under Alice Paul’s window.
Before the guards can muster
enough men, each woman tells Alice her name. They report a large sum of
money has come into the Treasury that day, and that forty-one of them
would protest against her imprisonment on the picket line tomorrow.
Then, just as Vida Mulholland starts to sing a song, they are
manhandled off the grounds. But they can’t silence Vida’s song.
The next morning, November 10th, a picket line prepares to leave Headquarters, forty-one women divided into five groups.
The
first group leaves Headquarters led by Mrs. Brannan. As usual, they
carry gold-lettered banners and take up their silent statuesque
positions at the East and West gates.
A thick stream of
government workers pass the silent sentinels and applaud when they
arrested. "Keep it up" someone yells, "They’ll give it to you."
The
second group of pickets number ten women. They too have banners and
flags when they leave Cameron House. They, too, are arrested at the
gates. The same happens to the third and fourth contingent. The last
group, led by the frail and lame seventy-year-old Mary Nolan, gallantly
takes up their posts. The onlookers applaud as they are arrested.
These
forty-one women are tried on November 12th and charged with obstructing
traffic. They plead not guilty. The judge dismisses the case.
No
sooner do these ladies return to Headquarters than they are back on the
line. The police are dumbfounded. They arrest the pickets, but have to
commandeer passing cars to take them to the police station.
Meantime, Alice languishes in solitary.
Doris
begs Dudley to do something. Together they go to see the warden. Dudley
argues that Alice and the others have civil rights and among them is a
right to counsel.
The warden tells them, "I make the rules at
District Jail. No one can see Miss Paul or any of them other
prisoners." Dudley vows to institute habeas corpus proceedings and
threatens to appeal to a higher authority.
Dudley calls on the
President. The First Lady sits in the background making bandages for
the Red Cross. Dudley protests the horrific circumstances under which
the pickets are now being held.
The President disavows any
knowledge of the particular circumstances of imprisonment. Dudley knows
better. He reminds the President that both the judge who gave Alice
Paul her seven-month sentence and the warden who holds her
incommunicado are his appointments.
The President refuses to
budge. Dudley resigns his post, telling President Wilson he will fight
as hard for the political freedom of women as he has always fought for
what he thought was the President’s liberal leadership. The President
is crushed. Edith, outraged, calls Dudley a traitor.
Rats scurry
about Alice’s filthy cell. A charwoman is let in to retrieve the toilet
bowl and slips Alice a note. Before Alice can read it, the cell door
crashes open and the warden struts in demanding Alice call off the
hunger strike or "I will force-feed every last one of you myself."
Though
pale and wan, Alice is calm and outwardly confident. She tells the
warden, "When you treat us as the political prisoners we are, we shall
eat. We’ve not offended against any law but rather the President. We
are entitled to due process."
Outraged, the warden threatens
Alice with a place far worse than District Jail if she says one more
word against the President. Just then they crack the eggs.
Back
at the White House, the warden reports to the President. "Everyday more
and more ladies are arrested. I don’t have the manpower and resources
to force-feed any more women." Edith rubs her husband’s shoulders
hoping to ease his pain. "That woman is insane." Edith suggests. "She
should be institutionalized."
The charwomen shows up with
another note but tells Doris this will be the last one because Miss
Paul has been transferred to St. Elizabeth’s - the government insane
asylum. "You’d be proud of Miss Paul." She boasts to Doris. "It takes
four strong men to hold her down to force feed her. Poor thing, soon as
she hears them eggs cracking, she gags."
Doris is beside
herself. But what can she do? She keeps the press informed and women on
the picket line. There are 34 women in three different penal
institutions. She must talk to Alice, but how?
Doris dons a pair of trousers, a seedy overcoat and pulls her hair under a hat. She hails a taxi.
ST. ELIZABETH’S INSANE ASYLUM
Doris sneaks onto the grounds of St. Elizabeth’s. A full moon lights up the night. Doris checks her map.
She
finds Alice’s window and takes a handful of beans out of her pocket.
She aims at the window. After several tries, she finds her mark. Much
to her relief, Alice lifts the window. When she peers down, Doris
catches her breath.
Alice is emaciated, frail, and ghost-like.
Despite her appearance, Alice hurls questions at Doris. Before she can
answer, a guard pounces on Doris pushing her out of earshot. "I’ll lock
you up too, if you don’t get out of here, young lady. You’re not
fooling anyone."
The next day, an old black man, the caretaker,
throws a ladder up against Alice’s window. He climbs up and apologizes
to Alice saying it is his job. He has orders to nail boards to her
window. As the final board deprives her of light and fresh air, tears
stream down Alice’s face.
In the asylum, Alice is strapped to the bed. The moaning and groaning inmates are heart breaking.
Suddenly,
a psychiatrist enters Alice’s room. He pulls a chair up, sits down and
begins to question her. Though weak, Alice is lucid. She discourses on
the meaning of Justice within a Democracy. She quotes the President.
The doctor is surprised. This is not what he expected.
When the
doctor returns to the White House, he tells the President, "I felt
myself in the presence of an unusually gifted personality. Miss Paul is
a woman of conviction; confident that Right is on her side, and God,
too. Think of Miss Paul," he tells the President, "as you would think
of Joan of Arc. She will die, but she will never give up."
The
doctor is scarcely out the door, when the President explodes. "I can’t
let this trivial issue sway public opinion against me." Edith knows he
is right.
Strapped to the bed, Alice prays that women will never
ever have to go through this again. Quite unexpectedly, a newspaperman
is let into her room. He is surprised to see the restraints, but begins
to ask Miss Paul a lot of questions.
Alice knows David Lawrence
is the President’s man. When he asks what it would take for her to give
up her tactics, Alice tells him nothing short of an amendment
enfranchising American women. American women are as entitled to vote as
American men.
The reporter urges her to give up the theatrics.
She tells him the hunger strike will be over when the administration
treats us as political prisoners. "Impossible!" He says, "It would be
easier to give you the vote than to treat you as political prisoners."
That night Alice goes to sleep with a smile on her face.
A few days later, suddenly and without explanation, the government releases all the prisoners.
The
women celebrate in a colorful mass meeting at Belasco Theater adjacent
to the White House. As the President and First Lady leave the White
House grounds in their new limo, they cannot ignore the overflow crowd
that has gathered to pay homage to Alice Paul and her fellow prisoners.
The
theater is packed to the rafters. Ninety-one prisoners, dressed in
white and carrying tri-colored flags and gold-lettered banners, march
down the center of the aisle toward the stage. Known as the "Prison
Specialists" they wear reproductions of their prison garb and carry a
sign that reads: Resistance to tyranny is obedience to God.
The
celebration turns into a fundraiser when $86,000 is pledged. Two
touching contributions move the audience: one of 50 cents, the other of
30 cents, arrives by messenger from Occoquan Workhouse because "…the
strange ladies helped us so much here."
Dudley takes the stage
and presents each prisoner with a tiny silver replica of a cell door.
When Alice’s name is called, the audience leaps to its feet, applauding.
Later
that night, while Alice and Lucy plot the party’s congressional
strategy, Dudley asks Doris to marry him. Doris accepts and tells him
that she will never be a passive housewife. He tells her he loves her
just the way she is.
At the White House, the President fears
Alice’s strategy will give the Republicans credit for the passage of
the Amendment. He calls to the White House his prominent Democratic
supporters and declares his support for the Susan B. Anthony Amendment.
The New York Times calls the President’s shift "a surprise."
The
President says he has been persuaded by the need to reward women for
their work on the war effort. He knows how hard women are working for
the nation. His daughter Margaret donates the proceeds from her singing
to the Red Cross. Eleanor supervises a Red Cross storeroom. And Edith?
She’s turned the White House into a model of wartime sacrifice.
She
and the President observe meatless days and make sacrifices just like
everybody else. To save the cost of cutting the lawn, Edith borrows a
flock of Shropshire sheep from a Virginia farm. The profit from the 98
pounds of wool collected is donated to the states and designated for
the war effort. In Kansas two pounds of White House wool brings in five
thousand dollars. In total, the wool will fetch fifty thousand dollars.
January
10, 1918. Alice and co-workers take front row seats in the Gallery of
the House of Representatives. Voting is about to begin on the Susan B.
Anthony Amendment. Edith’s expression turns frosty when she sees
National Women’s Party members take their places in the balcony.
Alice’s secret poll shows they are two votes short.
Applause
breaks out and heads turn to the Speaker’s door as old Congressman Mann
walks in trembling, aided by a cane and caretaker. He looks as if he is
at death’s door. Alice had counted him out because he had been
bedridden for so long. Doris slips into a seat next to Alice and grabs
her hand; "Well-done my dear, well done, but I fear we are still going
be one short."
But she is wrong. When the 274th vote is cast in
favor of suffrage, a cry of joy echoes in the halls and spills outside
where crowds celebrate the news. Outside the gallery, a woman begins to
sing, Praise God From Whom All Blessings Flow and song fills these
hallowed marble halls.
Though the ladies are elated, Miss Paul
corrals her troops and tells them, "This is no time to celebrate. This
victory is worthless unless we can convince 64 Senators to vote for the
amendment. "We can’t assume," Alice says, "just because the President
supported passage of the amendment in the House, doesn’t mean he will
also use his influence in the Senate."
Alice calls a halt to all
the dramatic actions against the President and instead pressures
recalcitrant Senators. She buttonholes Senators and lobbies Republicans
to vote for the amendment so they could take the credit for its
passage. She dispatches delegates to the states to urge voters to
pressure their Senators.
At Headquarters, an army of
stenographers works day and night. Press conferences are a daily
happening. The lobbying campaign yields nine of the eleven votes needed.
Only the President, Alice figures, can muster the last votes. She bombards him with phone calls, letters and delegations.
At
the eleventh hour, Wilson gives in and goes to the Senate to urge
support the passage of a federal amendment. He asks for its passage as
a war measure, assuring the Senators that the voices of the foolish and
intemperate don’t influence him. But everyone knows why he is there.
The amendment is defeated. Alice isn’t surprised. The President has waited too long and didn’t put his heart into it.
Before
the Senate recesses, Alice leads a group to the Capitol. They wear
black armbands to commemorate the death of Justice in the United States
Senate. They are arrested but the charges are dismissed.
At the
war’s end in November of 1918, President Wilson announces he will go to
Europe to work personally on the details of the peace agreement. Alice
tells reporters, "When the President and Mrs. Wilson leave for the
Peace Conference in Paris, and he will still hear our voices, even in
Paris."
The President sails for Europe to negotiate the peace.
He presents himself as the Champion of Liberty. At home Alice works to
set the record straight and plans a new dramatic action.
On
Christmas, 1918, Alice spends the day in bed, thinking and planning.
She comes up with a new idea she calls "Watch fires of Freedom."
WATCHFIRES OF FREEDOM
On
New Year’s Day a large urn and load of wood, sent from every state in
the union, are deposited at the Whites House pavement in line with the
front door.
A bell at Headquarters tolls and a large group of women march to the urn.
Alice
Paul lights a fire in an urn and announces, "Every time the President
makes a speech for Democracy abroad, we will toll a bell and burn his
words at home."
Mrs. Lawrence Lewis reads the words Wilson
recently spoke at Buckingham Palace, "We have used the words "right"
and "justice", and now we are to prove whether or not we understand
these words."
A group of soldiers and sailors rush forward, overturn the urn, and try to stamp out the blazing wood.
Suddenly
there is an exclamation from the crowd and everyone turns to see flames
come from a huge bronze urn in Lafayette Square directly opposite the
bonfire. Hazel Hunkins, clinging to the high-pedestal urn, is holding
the suffrage colors. Policemen rushed in and arrest her, Alice Paul and
three others. In the meantime, the fire in front of the White House is
rebuilt.
Briefly detained at the station, Alice and her
compatriots are released and return to stand guard over their watch
fire through the night.
Though this is the first of many fires
kindled by the Woman’s Party, it is the last time the women will be
released. Scores of women will be incarcerated; many will go on a
hunger strike.
Though these actions embarrass the President and
hurt his peace efforts, Alice Paul and the National Woman’s Party will
not let up. On February 9th, they make another dramatic move.
A
bell tolls at Headquarters and Alice leads a procession of a hundred
women to Lafayette Monument. A slight mist and the dying sun make their
colorful banners look like soft sails. The procession carries lighted
torches. The crowd is silent, awe-struck. Alice kindles a fire in an
urn and burns a black and white sketch of the President, pointing out
that every Anglo-Saxon government in the world except the United States
has enfranchised its women. Alice is grabbed by a policeman and thrown
into a police wagon. All the women are arrested.
In Paris, after
a hard day’s negotiating, the President receives the news. Edith is
aghast at Alice’s newest outrage: burning her husband in effigy. A
cable arrives from Margaret begging her father to put his full support
behind the Amendment before Republicans take credit for what is surely
coming. The vote is evenly divided in the Senate, she reports. The
President, his face twitching painfully, fears Alice’s new tactics will
discredit his effort to secure a just and lasting peace. The President
summons Senator Harris, who is in Italy, to Paris and asks him, as a
personal favor, to vote for the amendment.
While the issue is
being passionately debated in caucus, Harris’ pro-vote arrives by wire.
Just as in the House, the Amendment passes by the exact number needed
and The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be
denied or abridged by the United States or by any other state on
account of sex. Motion picture cameras are there to record the event.
At
Headquarters, when confirmation comes Doris remarks, "This seems such a
dull ending to such a dramatic struggle." "End!" Alice barks. "This
isn’t the end. We must get 36 out of our 48 states to ratify the
amendment. We can’t vote yet. Our work is laid out for us."
While
Alice Paul and the national Women’s Party focus their attention on the
states, Wilson returns from Europe with a peace plan.
Congress
is cool to his idea and criticism of Wilson mounts in Washington.
Despite Dr. Grayson’s warning, the President takes his grand vision to
the people. Hoping to gather support, he whistle-stops across the
country. Alice’s troops are at every stop to point out the
discrepancies in the President’s rhetoric. This infuriates Edith.
VICTORY
By
September of 1919, the President’s grueling schedule takes its toll.
First, the President stumbles through a speech in Utah. His trembling
hands, gray color and halting speech give Edith a terrible premonition.
Then one evening while traveling through Pueblo, Colorado, Woodrow
suffers a paralytic stroke and is incapacitated.
In an ironic
twist, the First Lady, Edith Bolling Galt Wilson, takes the reins of
power, orders the train back to Washington and throws a curtain up
around her husband.
From now on Edith stands between the
President and his most trusted advisors. She is the only means of
communication with the President. From the dreary executive wing where
Wilson lies paralyzed, Edith administers the most powerful government
in the world.
The President’s signature bears so little
resemblance to what it had looked like before that many believe she is
forging his name. Edith claims the discrepancy is because the President
lacks a hard surface for writing.
The President’s faithful
secretary, Joseph Tumulty, is slow to realize that Edith is keeping him
from the President. Colonel House, on the other hand, sees the truth
immediately. After all those years of serving the President, Colonel
House never sees Wilson again. And Tumulty only gets a remote glimpse
of the man he once served so faithfully. Edith’s charade is made
possible with the help of Dr. Grayson.
To keep the charade
going, Edith props her husband up in the window each afternoon. That is
as close as anyone can get to him. Meantime, Edith ignores the gossip
about a "petticoat government" and takes charge, firing a Cabinet
member who challenges her authority.
Word spreads that Edith Wilson is running the government.
At
Headquarters as well as in the nation’s newspapers, the First Lady is
referred to as the "presidentress". Alice doesn’t believe the rumors
are true. She will not be distracted from her mission.
Thirty-five
states have ratified, one to go. She decides to pay the President a
call, intending to convince him to use his persuasive voice to secure
the last state
When Alice arrives at the White House, she states
she will not leave until the President sees her. Rather than create a
scene, Edith sees her.
There is a quiet but intense difference
of opinion. Each woman makes herself perfectly clear. Alice says her
freedom fighters will not be stopped. The showdown will be in
Tennessee. Edith is confident that a southern state like Tennessee will
never ratify.
In Tennessee, Alice pressures the Governor and
threatens to defeat his party in the coming elections unless he uses
his political muscle to urge other Democratic heavies to support the
amendment. One beautiful, long red rose arrives for the Governor. It is
the red rose of the anti-suffragists. Edith has sent one to her old
friend, Governor Roberts.
As the vote approaches, the main hotel
in Nashville is bursting with pro, and anti-suffrage forces from all
over the nation. Although Tennessee is a dry state, there are a lot of
red-nosed, jovial legislators who strut about exalting the male who has
always protected the female.
Alice sets up her Headquarters in
the middle of the hotel’s lobby. The purple, gold and white of suffrage
clash with the ruby red rose of the "antis."
Someone remarks the "presidentress" is a suffragist’s dream come true. Alice is not amused.
There
are rumors of bribes and filibusters. Mysterious men with briefcases
huddle in corners. Legislators are hustled into elevators by aides and
carried to the 8th floor where there is a loud, boisterous party for
men only. A bartender dispenses moonshine. Dudley overhears two men
plot to kidnap a pro-Senator. Another group schemes to cross the state
line so they’d be unable to muster a quorum.
In the lobby, Doris
and others keep Alice apprised of what is going on. They are all agreed
that only one more vote is needed. The most likely candidate they think
is the youngest legislator, Harry Burns. But Harry sports the red rose
of the antis. Doris tells Alice that Harry’s mother is an ardent
suffragist.
Alice calls on Mrs. Burns. She tells the young
Congressmen’s mother that Harry is under tremendous pressure from the
Party to vote against ratification. Mrs. Burns says, "I know. Harry-boy
is all riled up over the threats some folks are making. He wants a
political career real bad. But he’s a good boy. I think he’ll do what’s
right."
Mrs. Burns, however, is concerned about another matter
and says, "You know, Miss Paul, I wonder if getting the vote will
really solve our problems."
Mrs. Burns tell s Alice her father,
recently deceased, lived in New York and left his estate to her, his
only daughter. The problem, she tells Alice, is that she is married and
lives in Tennessee. Under Tennessee law, she does not have the right to
inherit. The money went to her husband.
"No, it is true," Alice,
tells her, "voting will not solve that problem. A federal amendment is
the first step and we must move heaven and earth to make sure Tennessee
ratifies."
"Well, don’t you worry about my boy, Harry," Mrs. Burns tells Alice.
Alice
isn’t so confident. Threats are threats and if the boy sincerely wants
to be a politician he might well vote with the antis.
Will he or won’t he becomes the overriding question of the day.
August
18, 1920. Voting day. Alice and her cohorts escort each and every pro
Senator to the Legislature to thwart any kidnapping plans the "antis"
might have. One Senator doesn’t know what to make of his escort but
Doris assures him it is for their own protection.
When Alice spies Harry Burns in the corridor, her face falls. Harry wears the red rose of the opposition.
The
floor and the gallery of the Tennessee State Legislature are dotted
with red roses. Alice and Doris note that 96 of 99 Senators are
present. A motion is made to table the suffrage resolution. An angry
cry goes up from the floor. The Speaker bangs his gavel and orders the
women off the floor and into the balcony. There is an intense stillness.
One
by one, the Senators cast their votes. Alice sees a page deliver a note
to Harry Burns. When it’s Harry’s turn, he stands, takes off his red
rose and puts it on the table and declares loudly and clearly yes, for
ratification.
An uproar of enthusiasm greets Harry’s vote.
Alice, Doris, Dudley and the rest of the gang are ecstatic. They hug
and kiss co-workers.
Dudley remarks, "It’s too bad so much energy and suffering had to be expended for so simple a right."
The
Speaker tries to restore order. After the final vote is cast Alice and
the others leave the Chamber. A reporter runs up to Miss Paul, and asks
if she has a statement to make on this momentous occasion.
"When
Tennessee ratified the 15th amendment today," she tells him,
"twenty-six million American women acquired exactly the same power at
the ballot box as their husbands and brothers have."
Someone
yells from the crowd, "You did it, Miss Paul." Alice shakes her head
humbly, "No. You did it. You proved we are a government of the people.
The triumph is yours.
We transition to the retirement community. The sun is setting. Jess wants to know what happened to everyone?
Doris tells her, "Well, Woodrow Wilson died in 1924. He never did recover from his stroke.
"And
the First Lady? She died in 1961. She refused to vote right up till the
end. Your grandfather, rest his soul, and I used to get a big chuckle
out of that.
"And Miss Paul, well, she knew Mrs. Burns was right. Getting the vote certainly didn’t solve all the problems women faced.
"Headquarters
was as busy as ever. I remember a funny Texas case Alice Paul worked on
after the Amendment passed. A woman, I don’t remember her name, had
been elected to office in Texas, but she needed her husband’s
permission to take office. Things like that rankled Alice. The idea
that a woman couldn’t inherit made her furious. So one day, she just
sat down and drafted another amendment to the Constitution that she
thought would solve the problem once and for all. She called it the
Equal Rights Amendment. It simply said, "Equality of rights under the law shall not be abridged by the United States or any other State on account of sex."